Your Next
Grail Card
Starts Here.
From rookie cards and sealed boxes to vintage memorabilia and grading services — we're the shop where collectors find what they've been hunting for.
Trusted Local
Shop
Cards, Boxes & Everything In Between
Whether you're building a hobby wall or hunting for that one card to complete your set, we stock the products collectors actually want.
Sealed Product
Topps, Panini, Upper Deck and more — boxes, blasters, and single packs for every sport and hobby tier.
Single Cards
Rookies, parallels, autographs and memorabilia cards — sorted by sport, team, and player so you find what matters.
Vintage & Graded
Older releases, slabs, and graded gems from the golden eras — hand-picked inventory that holds value.
Memorabilia
Jerseys, balls, posters, and authenticated pieces that bring your man cave or office to life.
Protective Supplies
Sleeves, top loaders, penny sleeves, binders, and slabs — everything you need to keep your collection safe.
Buy · Sell · Trade
Bring your duplicates, your loose inventory, or your sealed products. We offer fair offers and honest appraisals every time.
More Than Just Cards on a Shelf
We're your full-service collectible destination — from the first box you crack to the slab you send away.
Grading Services
Submit your candidates for professional grading. We'll help you choose the right service and get your cards to the slabbers.
Buy & Sell
Have inventory you want to move? We buy singles, lots, and complete collections at competitive market rates.
Community Hub
A place to meet fellow collectors, share pulls, and get advice — no matter your experience level or what you collect.
Fair Appraisals
Not sure what your collection is worth? Bring it in and we'll give you an honest, no-pressure evaluation.
Delaware, OH
26 W Winter St
Built for Collectors,
Run by One.
Neuhart Cards & Sports Collectibles isn't a big-box store with aisles of plastic. It's a focused, curated shop where every box on the shelf and every binder on the rack has been selected with real collector knowledge.
Located right on Winter Street in downtown Delaware, we've become the go-to spot for hobbyists who want someone who actually understands the product — not just the price tag. Whether you're pulling your first box of hobby or liquidating a thirty-year collection, we treat you the same: with respect and straight answers.
We stock the latest releases from every major manufacturer, keep vintage inventory rotating, and maintain a solid supply of protective materials so you can shop once and be set.
100%
Locally Owned
4
Sports Covered
B·S·T
Buy · Sell · Trade
Find Us in Downtown Delaware
Easy to find, easy to park, and always open for business during our posted hours.
Address
26 W Winter St
Delaware, OH 43015
Phone
(740) 417-4877Hours
Have a Question or Want to Sell?
Send us a message and we'll get back to you as soon as possible. Whether it's about pricing, availability, or anything else — we're happy to help.
Call or text
(740) 417-4877Email us
neuhartcards@aol.comMessage Sent!
Thanks for reaching out. We'll get back to you within 24 hours.
